A skincare brand came to us with a familiar problem: their conversion rate was 1.2%. They'd redesigned their landing page three times. New photography, faster load times, bigger "Add to Cart" button. Nothing moved the needle.
Then we looked at where the traffic was coming from. A creator they'd partnered with had posted a video about her acne journey, mentioning their salicylic acid cleanser. Thousands of people clicked through - and landed on a page that said "Reveal Your Natural Radiance."
Not a word about acne. Not a mention of salicylic acid. Not a single before-and-after. The people arriving with a specific concern were met with generic aspirational copy. Of course they bounced.
The message-match problem
This happens constantly in beauty. Brands invest heavily in driving traffic - through creators, paid ads, PR coverage - but treat the destination as an afterthought. Everyone lands on the same product page regardless of why they clicked.
Think about it from the customer's perspective. A creator you trust just explained how this product helped clear her breakouts. You're interested, you click through, and you're met with dreamy lifestyle imagery and copy about "luminous, dewy skin." The disconnect is jarring.
What message matching looks like in practice
The fix isn't complicated, but it does require intentionality.
For creator campaigns: Create landing pages that mirror the creator's language and concerns. If the creator talked about sensitive skin, the landing page should lead with sensitive skin messaging. Pull a quote from their video. Show the same use case they demonstrated.
For paid ads: Your ad copy and your landing page copy should feel like the same conversation. If the ad says "clinically proven to reduce dark spots in 4 weeks," the landing page headline shouldn't say "Your Best Skin Awaits." It should say "Clinically Proven to Reduce Dark Spots in 4 Weeks" - and then show the evidence.
For different audiences: A first-time visitor needs education and trust signals. A returning visitor needs a reason to buy now. A customer who abandoned cart needs reassurance. These shouldn't all see the same page.
The skincare brand's results
We created four variants of their landing page, each matched to a specific traffic source and concern:
- Acne-focused (for creator traffic discussing breakouts)
- Anti-ageing (for their Google Ads targeting that keyword)
- Sensitive skin (for their partnership with an eczema community)
- General (for organic and direct traffic)
Same product. Same price. Different conversations.
Their conversion rate went from 1.2% to 3.8% within six weeks. No redesign. No new photography. Just words that matched what people came looking for.
The uncomfortable implication
Most beauty brands are sitting on the same problem. They spend 90% of their effort getting people to the site and 10% on what happens when they arrive. Flipping that ratio - even slightly - often delivers better returns than any amount of additional traffic spend.
Before you redesign your landing page, ask a simpler question: does it continue the conversation that brought someone here? If not, the design doesn't matter.